
Paneer Butter Masala Recipe – Cashew and Tomato Gravy
Paneer butter masala recipe with cashew paste, onion, tomato and butter. Paneer is tossed in butter, then folded into the gravy. Serves 3 in 40 minutes. This paneer butter masala has a smooth red gravy made from onion, tomato and soaked cashews, with a few whole spices to start. The paneer is tossed in a little butter in a separate pan first, so it picks up the butter and loses its extra moisture before it meets the gravy. Paneer (ponir in Bengali) and butter (makhon) are the two things that make this dish, so use fresh paneer and keep the flame medium when the butter goes in, otherwise it browns and turns bitter. Soak the cashews 30 minutes ahead; that wait is not counted in the cooking time.
By What I Can Cook WithPublished Updated Editorial policy
- Diet
- Vegetarian
- Serves
- 3
- Total time
- 40 min
- Ingredients
- 21
- Steps
- 8
Scales ingredients for 3 servings
Ingredients (21)
Main items
200 gPaneerपनीर · পনিরcut into cubes
2 pcOnionप्याज़ · পেঁয়াজmedium, finely chopped
2 pcTomatoटमाटर · টমেটোmedium, roughly chopped and blended
5 pcGreen Chiliहरी मिर्च · কাঁচা লঙ্কাmild ones, blended with the tomato; 5 to 6
30 gButterमक्खन · মাখনabout 3 small cubes, for tossing the paneer
2½ tspGarlicलहसुन · রসুন2 tsp finely chopped, ½ tsp as paste
½ tspGingerअदरक · আদাas fine paste
1 tspCreamमलाई · ক্রিমor milk malai from home
Spices & herbs
12 pcCashewकाजू · কাজুsoaked in hot water for 30 minutes; 10 to 12
1 pcBay Leafतेज पत्ता · তেজপাতাwhole
1 pcCinnamonदालचीनी · দারুচিনিsmall stick
2 pcCardamomइलायची · এলাচ1 black and 1 green
1½ tspCuminजीरा · জিরা1 tsp whole seeds for the tadka, ½ tsp powder for the masala
¾ tspTurmericहल्दी · হলুদ½ tsp for the gravy, ¼ tsp for the paneer
2 tspRed Chili Powderलाल मिर्च पाउडर · লাল লঙ্কা গুঁড়োdeep red mild kind such as Kashmiri or degi mirch
½ tspCoriander Seedधनिया · ধনেas coriander powder
1 tspKasuri Methiकसूरी मेथी · কসুরি মেথিcrushed between the palms, half in the gravy, half on the paneer
½ tspGaram Masalaगरम मसाला · গরম মশলাpowder
2 tbspCoriander Leavesधनिया पत्ता · ধনে পাতাfinely chopped, half in the gravy, half to finish
Preparation Steps
0 of 8 completedSoak the cashews and blend the tomato
Soak 12 cashews in hot water for 30 minutes. Meanwhile finely chop 2 onions. Roughly chop 2 tomatoes, then blend them with 5 green chillies and 1 tsp red chilli powder into a smooth puree. Rinse the jar with a splash of water and add that to the puree.
Temper the whole spices
Heat 2 tbsp oil in a kadhai. Add 1 bay leaf, 1 small cinnamon stick, 1 black cardamom, 1 green cardamom and 1 tsp cumin seeds. Add 2 tsp finely chopped garlic and cook on medium heat for a minute, without letting it turn brown.
Cook the onion and masala
Add the chopped onion and cook on medium-high heat, stirring often, until light golden. Stir in ½ tsp ginger paste and ½ tsp garlic paste and cook until the raw smell goes. Lower the heat and add ½ tsp turmeric and ½ tsp red chilli powder. Stir for a few seconds.
Cook the tomato puree
Pour in the tomato puree and add 1 tsp salt. Turn the heat to high and cook, stirring now and then, until the puree dries up and the oil starts to separate at the edges.
Add the ground spices
Add ½ tsp coriander powder, ½ tsp cumin powder and ½ tsp kasuri methi, crushed between your palms. Mix well. When the masala starts to stick, add a splash of water and cook on low heat until it turns soft and thick.
Add the cashew paste
Grind the soaked cashews with a little water into a very smooth paste and add it to the pan, rinsing the jar with a splash of water. Mix well, cover and cook on low heat for 3 to 4 minutes, stirring in between so it does not catch at the bottom. Cook until oil separates again. Add ½ tsp garam masala and 1 tbsp chopped coriander leaves and mix. Loosen the gravy with a little warm water if it is too thick.
Toss the paneer in butter
Put 30 g butter in a non-stick pan on medium heat and let it just start to melt. Add the paneer cubes, ¼ tsp turmeric, ½ tsp red chilli powder, ½ tsp kasuri methi and a pinch of salt. Cook on medium-high heat until the moisture dries off. Stir only a little, as paneer breaks if you keep turning it.
Mix paneer into the gravy and finish
Tip the paneer and all the butter from the pan into the gravy. Mix gently and heat for a minute. Finish with 1 tbsp chopped coriander leaves and 1 tsp cream (or home milk malai), mix and switch off the heat. Serve hot.
Smart Pantry Swaps & Storage for this Dish
How was this recipe?
Community RatingTap a star to rate this dish and help fellow home cooks.
Save to your favourites
Save this recipe to find it quickly anytime in your favourites.
Serving Suggestions
- •Serve hot with butter naan, tandoori roti or jeera rice
- •Pair with sliced onion and lemon wedges on the side
- •Goes well with plain paratha for a Sunday lunch
Storage & Reheating
Keeps in the fridge for 2 days in a closed box. Reheat on low heat with a splash of water, as the gravy thickens when cold.
Share this recipe
Cooking for family or friends? Send this recipe on WhatsApp in one tap, or copy the link to share it anywhere.
Adapted from trusted creators.








